Report on the Fourth Sat Paul Mittal National Inter-University Debate, 2008 on Population and Environment
I am truly honoured to have represented the Mizoram University once again in a nationwide debate competition organized by Indian Association of Parliamentarians on Population and Development (IAPPD). Earlier in November 2006, along with my partner Carolyn Zonunmawii, I competed against some forty contestants from universities across India on the motion “Migration Improves Environment” and fortunately, my argument against the proposition landed me in a second position. This time, however, it’s a different story.
To make an entry into this nationwide competition held during November 21st and 22nd, 2008, I won a debate jointly organized by IAPPD and MZU on the topic “Population growth is an essential for Development” on September 3, 2008, in which there two participants each from the various colleges in Aizawl under MZU. I spoke for the motion, and the runner-up, Rebecca Vanlalhumi, a first year student of English Dept. at Pachhunga University College, joined forces with the others in the treasury bench, qualifying herself for the Delhi round in November to be my teammate to represent MZU, in which the motion would be “Education Improves Environment.”
The time for us to go to Delhi was not an auspicious one, for the weather had been constantly holding up travellers at Lengpui airport, sometimes for days on end, because of blankets of mist. At the time when we were finally summoned and briefed by the office of Dean, Student’s Welfare, to prepare for our embarkation, we realized that almost all the planes were either cancelled or booked up. Just when we were about to lose any hope of getting tickets, the ticket lady somehow found two for us on her last ditch attempt. What a relief for us and the Dean!
The next day, which was November 20, without any major setback, we flew from Aizawl to Guwahati, and to Calcutta. There, catching a Delhi-bound flight at another airport nearby, we travelled on. When we landed at Delhi airport, however, we had to wait for almost one and half hour at the conveyor belt, along with co-passengers, who were getting enraged over the unnecessary delay caused by the mismanagement, just to get our luggage back.
Among the swarm of officious taxi drivers noisily vying for passengers at the airport even at this time, which was about 1:oo am, we hired a pre-paid taxi and started for NCUI Hostel at August Kranti Marg, an arranged destination for us the location of which I vaguely know about from memory and the taxi driver had not heard of. After a few rounds in the same square in our desperate attempt to locate the building, we approached a makeshift police patrol station. We were relieved when we finally got to the building following the instruction of the policemen. Waking up the reception personnel of the hostel building from his slumber, and getting our room allotted to us, we took shower and lied down to rest our tired bodies. However, sleep didn’t come easily. We couldn’t help turning over in our heads all the sudden hustle and bustle that we had bumped into just within the last forty eight or so hours. And here we were, just in time to take part in a serious competition that many students had put everything they had for. We knew our chance to beat them was slim; I knew I had to rely heavily on my sense of spontaneity that works best only when I have had a good sleep. But the insomnia was persistent.
Next morning, we met with other participants and their guides from different universities at breakfast. At 9:30 am, we were at the IAPPD Hall located across the street. When preliminary things like welcome speech, candle lighting, and introduction, were done, the competition started and the participants were randomly called out, university after university, to speak at the podium. We were unfortunate to have been the first to be called out, as all along we had been thinking that the sequence would follow an alphabetical order, giving us more time to get ourselves organized as we get the drift of the pattern of the argument after at least five speakers. This, I was sure, would put me where I could easily view the issue from some vantage point. Rebecca tried hard to sound eloquent and authoritative, but her discourse was marred by unwanted halts and some forgotten lines. She wasn’t at all satisfied at her performance. I was not better: for some reason, I couldn’t get my facts at my fingertips and my overreliance on my papers was obvious to the judges; and to make matters worse, my line of thought suffered serious blockage, rendering my speech sounded like those of an angry man’s hardly able to utter a word in his indignation. We attributed our unimpressive performances to the series of hassles we had faced during the last twenty four hours coupled with sleep deprivation. Moreover, we both had been busily engaged in our respective class studies even in the days leading up to competition. Looking back, I just hope in future whoever the participants from MZU may be, more attention be paid by University authorities for their preparation and journey early on.
During this day and the next day, there raged on a fierce verbal battle within the bounds of decency between the two sides. The many we saw performing on the stage were not only fluent but consumed. It was clear a lot of effort was put for perfecting such dramatic performances. On the other hand, there were also some weak performances. One participant got tongue tied and had to be rushed to the greenroom, aided by supporters, only to return later to read out his speech in a trembling voice, totally stripped of any inkling of energy and cogency that are indispensible to any moving oratory. I would have been able to understand all what the participants expressed if I spoke Hindi, for several participants used it so, but Rebecca seemed to be enjoying more the speeches rendered in Hindi than in their English counterparts.
Eventually in the evening when the result was declared, there seemed to be a general consensus as a young man named Prakram Singh Shekhawat from Devi Ahilya University, Indore, who spoke against the motion, lifted up the trophy that came complete with Rs. 15,000/- His partner, from the same university, came in second. Their joy was added as they resoundingly became the University Winner Team, for which they received another Rs 50,000/-
We spent the evening going shopping and making some phone calls. Already we had formed a group of friends in that pool of participants, in which everyone also had his or her own clique to hang out with. It was another sleepless night that night. After dinner our group huddled together at the room of one friend and we exchanged stories, from everything including our cultural backgrounds and way of living back homes, our hopes and dreams, to romantic lives and general philosophy in life, while joking about unceasingly till the crack of dawn. I wonder whether or not those in that room are still haunted to this day by the non sequitur lines and melody that Rebecca and I together gave to “Kan Zotlang Ram Nuam” and “Mal Min Sawm Turin” as we belted out songs of sort at their request.
Early the next morning, but not without first showing up at a wrong airport because of wrong direction the hostel receptionist had given us and then hurriedly making for the correct one during the still available time, we flew out of Delhi, traversing the airy trail we took across the sky three days before in that limitless expanse where clouds were our only friends, and stopping over at Calcutta airport for a change of plane. Although our planes soared high, my mind was ebbing low. I tried to console myself, but it was hard to figure out what exactly had happened to me as I was reconstructing the whole scene over and over again in my head, locating where I had tripped up, what I should have done differently for the competition. It was bad to realize that I let down my university, my friends, and my family, but somehow I was constantly reminding myself that loosing in dignity is just as important a virtue as winning in humility. Generally since early that morning Rebecca and I didn’t talk much, not that we were bored with each other or that we ran out of subject but there was some soul-searching to do for both of us. At about 12:00 pm we touched down Lengpui. As our plane was still moving along the runway a phone call caught my attention. It was a short, blunt talk as I informed the expectant Dean that we were unsuccessful. It might be easy for us to shrug off what had happened to us and get a move on, but I couldn’t help feeling sorry for Dr. Lalrintluanga, Dean of Student’s Welfare, MZU, and his office because of their great faith in us, even working beyond the call of duty in order for us to get to Delhi on time, and boldly entering an arrangement tantamount to a huge financial gamble just for our sake.
In the two times that I have been to Delhi debates, I feel greatly privileged to have been picked to represent a young university. I wish I had done it the second time round, but as the saying goes, “every dog has its day.” MZU has been a blessing to me, and I’ll never forget how it has opened the doors for me. And although my second trip proved to be technically a failure, I came home more certain than before that students from this corner of India have the potential to compete with, even tower above, the students from any other part of India. We only have to show a little more interest and confidence in our nature as academicians and scholars. I hope what little I have achieved during my time is just the beginning of a breakthrough to be followed up, modified, mastered, and handed down by next-generation MZU students to their successors. How I wish this could be my legacy.
Truly, this journey was not without benefits. Besides gaining access to a very important platform, I crossed path with some new, wonderful friends, including an English Literature professor, whom I am still in contact with today. I felt glad just to be a part of this exciting atmosphere where there is a genuine discussion at the national on the state of our environment, and how as citizens we should respond to its urgent call. I am hopeful that those who have personally experienced educated dialogues of this kind will do everything in their power to address the problems of exploding population and environmental degradation so that India will lead the world when it comes saving our planet. Ultimately, it’s not about winning the contention but getting things done that is important in today’s world of environmental emergency. Image of the Indian representative at the UN for a long time, who was the Chief Guest at the event, comes to my mind, particularly of our brief meeting on the morning of November 21st during tea-break as he put this question to me in English resembling a native speaker’s: “Do you have an environmental group of some kind or the other in your university?” I felt guilty to say “No.”
Monday, July 13, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment